Does it make sense for the Detroit Red Wings to trade for the now-injured Stephen Weiss?

Crank up the Trade Machine!

Crank up the Trade Machine!

Now that Florida’s Stephen Weiss, premium chum for the fake trade waters, is out for the season due to wrist surgery, he’s fallen out of the public eye just enough so we can take a brief interlude from the James Mungro Memorial Award to talk about him.

Before Weiss’s surgery, it was the Red Wings were interested according to the Ottawa Sun’s Bruce Garrich. The Red Wings want to add more depth up front. With the Red Wings in the thick of the playoff run, Weiss isn’t going to be any help sitting in the press box.

But with the Red Wings seemingly outside of the circle of NHL Elites this season, should they still try to swing a deal for him in order to have him for the 2013-14 season? And is it possible to do so without hurting your team this season? Weiss is set to become a free agent at the end of this year. The Red Wings could pick him up for nothing this summer. Or we could have the Parise/Suter Saga Part Three and Detroit could sitting there, again, putting a contact offer on the table only to have Weiss’s agent use it to clean up coffee spills.

Nothing is guaranteed in July. If the Red Wings can swing a deal with a Panthers organization desperate to get anything for him in order to exclusively negotiate a contract extension with Weiss, isn’t it worth it? I mean, this guy is the bees knees.

I guess that all depends on how much you, acting as the Red Wings manager, are willing to give up. A recent trade may give us some insight into the going rate for a player of  Weiss’ caliber.

Weiss accumulated 57 points last year for the Panthers, just two less than a player that was the talk of trade market for a solid six months last year: Rick Nash. Now, Nash scored 59 points for a horrible team and is generally regarded as a better player than Weiss, but his deal can give us a starting point. Here’s the full deal the Rangers made for the Blue Jackets to acquire the services of Nash:

  • New York gets: Rick Nash (59 points), a conditional third-round pick, and minor league defenseman Steve Delisle.
  • Columbus gets: Brandon Dubinsky (34 points), Artem Anisimov (36 points), defensive prospect Tim Erixon and a first round pick.

Let’s not worry ourselves with minor league throwaways. This was basically Rick Nash for two NHL players, a prospect and an upgrade of two rounds in the draft. Add a broken wrist, Weiss scoring those points on a good team last year instead of the worst in the league and him not being Rick Nash, and you probably drop an NHL player and lesson the quality of the draft the pick.

So who does Detroit send the other way? Well if the Red Wings are looking for depth at forward this season and still believe they’re in the playoff race, which they obviously are, they’re not going to give up any NHL-ready forwards, or anybody they think can contribute points down the road, like Gustav Nyquist.

After just about every defensemen getting hurt in the early stage of the season, they’re all coming back. All of the sudden the Red Wings have a superfluous amount of average/slightly above average defensemen. One of them could go. Which one? Well if there’s a motto in Sunrise it’s “Always Build for the Future.” Weiss is 29. Anybody 27 and up is probably too old or too good for the Red Wings to give up. The Red Wings probably believe too much in Brenden Smith (24) to send him packing. Brian Lashoff (22) is a candidate, but he’s just signed a three-year extension. Management has to feel it has something. Then there’s Jakub Kindl (26).

Kindl has been OK, but not the type two-way defenseman the Red Wings thought they were getting when they drafted him 19th overall in 2005. A change of scenery might be good for him. Plus, the Panthers are looking for two-way defensemen.

There’s your NHL player. The Panthers are going to need another prospect, a high-end one that’s going to hurt the Red Wings a little. How about another defenseman? Ryan Sproul is slated to be a good offensive defensemen in a couple of years. He’s got 54 points in 61 games for the Sault Ste. Marie Greyhounds in the OHL this year (EDIT: those were actually stats last year. He has 64 points in 45 games this year) and is just about the same caliber of prospect as Tim Erixon.

Swap late round picks and you’ve could have a deal here:

  • Detroit gets: Stephen Weiss, 7th round pick
  • Florida gets: Jakub Kindl, Ryan Sproul, 5th round pick

Fair trade? Fair trade for a guy with a broken wrist? I’ll stop asking myself questions now.

13 comments on “Does it make sense for the Detroit Red Wings to trade for the now-injured Stephen Weiss?

  1. I don’t think Holland will trade a future top 4 D which we would need in a coupe in the future!

  2. That’s a good point, but you have to give up something if you want to get something. If this was to go down, maybe the trade is altered where the Red Wings ask for a lesser defenseman in return as well?

    • Yeah, but i don’t think Holland would take such a huge risk on a pending free agent! We are pretty deep with forwards right now too. We could always try to find a top 6 forward in free agency!

  3. Kindle is to good to give away. Give them coliacavo and Samuelson

    • Coliacavo and Samuelsson isn’t anywhere close to taking what the Panthers would want for Weiss. Sounds like you’d just rather not make the trade then. Fair enough. I think the Red Wings feel the same way.

  4. Detroit cannot afford to trade away good D prospects, especially prospects with a ceiling as high as Sproul. (Sproul actually has 19g 45a – 64pts in 45 games this season and leads all OHL defensemen in scoring. Codi Ceci is 2nd with 59pts, but he’s played in 64 games).

    I like the idea of landing Weiss, but giving all that up for a pending UFA that could very well sign elsewhere in July makes no sense. Unless Florida is prepared to let him go for a mid-round pick, I would wait until he hits the market in July.

    • The condition I was going on would be that Weiss would agree in principle to a contact extension with the Red Wings before the trade (he’s got a no trade clause). As for the Sproul stats, you’re right. I was looking at his stats for last year. I’ll make the changes. Thanks.

      • Hypotetical: What if we swapped Sproul for Xavier Ouellet? Would that make the trade more suitable?

  5. I still don’t make the trade with Ouellet. Detroit just doesn’t have the luxury of giving up young D prospects.

    A better trade example (that instantly comes to mind) would be the Fisher to Nashville trade. Ottawa traded the 30year old Mike Fisher to Nashville for a 1st in 2011 and a 3rd in 2012 (was conditional on Nashville winning a playoff round). Fisher was still under contract for two more years (4.2M cap hit). Obviously FIsher and Weiss aren’t the same player, Weiss has more offensive upside/Fisher is a bigger body and stronger defensively. Also since Weiss is injured for the rest of the year, whatever team trades for him would be on the hook for the rest of his salary this season… that’s not a big deal for Detroit, but if Florida could save that money (approx. 1.25M remaining) on his salary this year that would be huge for them… but it also decreases his trade value.

    Detroit could probably snag Weiss using the same framework as the Fisher deal, a pick in this years draft and a conditional in next years draft depending on if he re-signs, if they make it far in the playoffs etc. Weiss in his current condition is not worth a 1st round pick, but maybe they could swing a deal for a conditional 5th this year (turns to a 2nd if he signs) and a conditional 4th next year if the Wings make it to the conference finals next year…. I don’t know something like that.

    That being said, I still don’t make the trade.

    • Good points. Hadn’t thought about the Fisher trade as a possible parallel. I also like the conditional picks idea, although I don’t think it would work is this hypothetical situation. I think the Wings don’t make a trade for an injured guy unless they know he’s going to sign an extension.

  6. Thought I’d just point out that the picture is not of Weiss. Weiss is on the bench by the ref’s shoulder. I think the guy is no.19, so it could be either Upshall if the picture is from last season or Reasoner if it’s the season before.

  7. This trade does not make sense. Holland needs to stop bring in post prime players and start building through the draft. The wings core going past the last lockout allowed free agent aquisitions to stay competative but now that those players have aged and moved on the wings only option is to build in the draft. No trades of our future for players that are just going to keep us meiocre or we’ll just end up the next Calgary Flames.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 546 other followers

%d bloggers like this: